Notes oN the FouNdiNg oF Logics aNd MetaLogic: aristotLe, BooLe, aNd tarski
نویسنده
چکیده
This paper is more a series of notes than a scholarly treatise. It focuses on certain achieve‐ ments of Aristotle, Boole and Tarski. The notes presented here using concepts introduced or formalized by Tarski contribute toward two main goals: comparing Aristotle’s system with one Boole constructed intending to broaden and to justify Aristotle’s, and giving a modern perspective to both logics. Choice of these three logicians has other advantages. In history of logic, Aristotle is the best representative of the earliest period, Boole the best of the transitional period, and Tarski the best of the most recent period. In philosophy of logic, all three were amazingly successful in having their ideas incorporated into mainstream logical theory. This last fact makes them hard to describe to a modern logician who must be continually reminded that many of the concepts, principles, and methods that are taken to be “natural” or “intuitive” today were all at one time discoveries.
منابع مشابه
Aristotle’s Prior Analytics and Boole’s Laws of Thought
Prior Analytics by the Greek philosopher Aristotle (384– 322 BCE) and Laws of Thought by the English mathematicianGeorge Boole (1815 – 1864) are the twomost important surviving original logical works from before the advent of modern logic. This article has a single goal: to compare Aristotle’s system with the system that Boole constructed over twenty-two centuries later intending to extend and ...
متن کاملProofs by handling polynomials: a tool for teaching logic and metalogic
1 Polynomials as proof devices Algebraic proof systems based on formal polynomials over algebraically closed fields (the “polynomial ring calculus”) were introduced in [9] (see [10] and [11] for recent developments). Formal polynomials work as a powerful tool for logical derivation in classical and non-classical logics, in particular for propositional many-valued logics, paraconsistent logics a...
متن کاملUna dualidad topológica para álgebras de boole bitopológicas
Las Álgebras de Boole Topológicas, llamadas también “Álgebras Interiores” o “Álgebras de Clausura”, fueron estudiadas por Tarski [5] y Naturman [2]. Los Espacios Bitopológicos, a su vez, fueron estudiados por [1]. En [3], se presentan las Álgebras de Boole Bitopológicas, que relacionan y generalizan naturalmente las estructuras anteriormente mencionadas. Entre otras aplicaciones, permiten dar u...
متن کاملMax-planck-institut F Ur Informatik Metalogical Frameworks K I N F O R M a T I K Im Stadtwald D 66123 Saarbr Ucken Germany Authors' Addresses Publication Notes
In computer science we speak of implementing a logic; this is done in a programming language, such as Lisp, called here the implementation language. We also reason about the logic, as in understanding how to search for proofs; these arguments are expressed in the metalanguage and conducted in the metalogic of the object language being implemented. We also reason about the implementation itself,...
متن کاملMax-planck-institut F ¨ Ur Informatik Metalogical Frameworks I N F O R M a T I K Authors' Addresses Publication Notes
In computer science we speak of implementing a logic; this is done in a programming language, such as Lisp, called here the implementation language. We also reason about the logic, as in understanding how to search for proofs; these arguments are expressed in the metalanguage and conducted in the metalogic of the object language being implemented. We also reason about the implementation itself,...
متن کامل